Skip to content
PULSE NEWS
Crime

Doctor in Mold Lawsuit Kills DC Building Manager, Police Say

Two years of emails, a hole in the drywall, and five minutes on Thursday morning.

Anna Lee, journalistBy Anna Lee
Doctor Murders Building Manager Over Mold
Photo by Jfeinstein | Dreamstime.com

An emergency room physician who had spent more than a year suing his condominium association over black mold shot and killed his building's manager inside a Logan Circle gym on Thursday morning, then fired on four more people from his seventh-floor balcony before killing himself, police said.

Police identified the gunman as Matt Lambert, 55, and the man killed as James Stuart, 46, the manager of the Metropole condominium in the 1500 block of 15th Street NW, about a mile north of the White House. Four other people were shot. One of them remains in critical condition.

Officers Were Inside the Gym Within 30 Seconds

The call came in just before 8 a.m. on Nov. 12. Interim Metropolitan Police Department Chief Jeffery Carroll said officers reached the scene within about 30 seconds and found one man dead inside VIDA Fitness, the gym on the ground floor of the building. Four more people had been shot nearby, including construction workers outside. All four were taken to hospitals.

Lambert retreated to his seventh-floor unit and barricaded himself inside. Carroll said he fired through his front door at officers on at least two occasions. No officers were hurt. Hostage negotiators reached him by phone, and during that conversation they heard a final gunshot and lost contact. Officers forced their way in and found him with what appeared to be a self-inflicted gunshot wound.

During the standoff, Lambert broke the gas line to his fireplace and started a fire, police said. Investigators found gasoline and other flammable materials in the apartment. The building's sprinkler system went off and helped contain the flames, and D.C. Fire shut off the gas. Three guns were recovered from the unit: a shotgun, a rifle and a handgun. Carroll said all three were used, none were registered to Lambert in Washington, and it appeared there was some level of planning behind the attack.

The Man Who Died Was a Witness in the Lawsuit

Stuart managed the Metropole and worked for EJF Real Estate Services.

Stuart was not a stranger to the litigation. Lambert's attorney, Joel Braithwaite, told reporters Stuart was a "central fact witness" in the case and "very pivotal in relaying information to the board." Braithwaite said he knew Stuart through the lawsuit and offered condolences to his family.

A Hole in the Drywall, Then Two Years of Emails

The paper trail starts in March 2023, when the Metropole Condominium Association began repairs to the building's facade. Lambert's complaint says his unit had no water damage and no sign of mold or moisture before that work started. Within a year, he reported water coming into his apartment.

In August 2024, the association cut a hole in his drywall to test for leaks. By September, the electric blind underneath the hole had shorted out, and Lambert said he could see and smell mold. The board denied there was mold and planned to patch and repaint, according to the complaint. Two independent assessors found both high moisture and mold, including "heavy" growth on the exterior wall. A ServPro inspection reported visible mold contamination on exterior and interior walls.

In October 2024, Lambert asked the board to pull the drywall, remediate, run more tests and produce a repair and reimbursement plan. The board replied by email and took no action, the complaint says. The next month, contractors he hired to tear out the walls and floors found black mold and leaking pipes, including a leak in the building's fire suppression system. He moved out on Nov. 11, 2024 and said he could not rebuild because the moisture never left. When he filed suit, the north window sills were still wet.

He Sued in March 2025 and Asked for $1 Million

Lambert filed in D.C. Superior Court in March 2025, accusing the condo board of negligence in maintaining the building, of poor planning and oversight of the facade job, and of ignoring warnings that repairs were needed. He also claimed the board never filed a claim with the building's insurance company to cover the damage to his unit. He was seeking $1 million.

By May, he put his own spending on investigating and responding to the damage at more than $290,000. Braithwaite said the fight had cost his client over $300,000 in total, and that Lambert described the condo as going from his prized possession to a war zone. The complaint was amended in July. The case was still open, with mediation set for March 2027.

The Association Blamed the Gym's Dryers

In the litigation, the condo association argued the moisture in Lambert's unit came from the laundry dryers at VIDA Fitness, the gym below his condo. The association and EJF denied causing the damage, said any damage was caused by third parties beyond their control, and said Lambert failed to limit his losses. Neither the association nor EJF responded immediately to requests for comment after the shooting.

An Account Called OfMiceandMold

An X account under the name @OfMiceandMold had become a running archive of complaints about the building, with dozens of posts, photos and videos of the damage and references to an "uninhabitable penthouse." At 8:06 a.m. Thursday, the account posted screenshots of an engineering report on the water damage and disrepair, with the line, "My manifesto is an engineering report."

On April 28, the account posted: "If you're looking for the building manager, I would check the gym."

On Oct. 1, it invoked Luigi Mangione, who pleaded guilty in August to federal charges in the 2024 killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson and had written "delay," "deny" and "depose" on his ammunition. The post said that after months of "'Luigi' tactics (delay, deny, defend) by the HOA," an independent engineering report had finally been submitted into the record, and promised to share it on X, with other Metropole owners and with Logan Circle realtors "when the time is right." Police had not confirmed that Lambert wrote the posts.

His Lawyer Spoke to Him on Tuesday

Braithwaite said he talked with Lambert two days before the shooting and thought he was in a "great head space." Lambert had just spoken at a conference about artificial intelligence in medicine and was due to start a new, better-paying job on Monday. After a deposition the previous week, the attorney believed his client felt the case was finally moving. He ended that last call thinking "things were looking up."

"The Dr. Lambert I know is a humanitarian, a philanthropist. He has [provided] scholarships for the medical kids through medical school. He is well loved; he's a musician, and he's a book writer... had a great sense of humor, and he loved fly fishing," Braithwaite said. "So I didn't even know him to own a weapon." He added that while nobody involved was happy with the case, there was no reason for anyone to act out like this. Asked whether anything in Lambert's life explained Thursday, he said, "I don't think there's any sense to be made. I can't give you that closure." The shooting fell on the anniversary of the day Lambert buried his mother.

Treadmills, a Fire Alarm and 99 Units

Michael Carney was on a treadmill at VIDA Fitness when it started. He told the Washington Sun he heard "one pop" and assumed an exercise ball had burst, then saw a victim on the floor. "Everyone was kind of just hiding behind planters and stuff," he said. Someone pulled a fire alarm. Once outside, he heard five or 10 more shots that seemed to come from a nearby alley.

A woman who had also been on a treadmill said there was no way out of the gym except past the body. "It was like chaos. It was horrific, honestly," she said. Jonathan Csapo, a BBC producer who lives in the building, came out of a fire escape and heard gunfire close by. "I could see the smoke, I could see the flash. We just all started running," he said. He was brought back inside to a safe room by a building manager.

A witness who was about 20 feet from the shooting said he lives directly below Lambert and had watched him grow increasingly upset at HOA meetings, sometimes inviting neighbors into his unit to see the condition it was in. He described the 99-unit building as a tight-knit community. His girlfriend barricaded herself in their apartment during the standoff. It is now under an inch of water from the response to the fire.

A Chemistry Degree, a Guitar and a $1,095,000 Condo

Lambert bought the one-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom penthouse in September 2016 for $1,095,000, according to D.C. tax records, and had lived there since 2017. He earned an undergraduate degree in chemistry at Marshall University and his medical degree at Marshall's Joan C. Edwards School of Medicine, then finished his emergency medicine residency at West Virginia University School of Medicine in 2000.

He was the founder and CEO of MLEM, a healthcare and technology consultancy, according to his LinkedIn profile. He worked for the Annapolis-based firm Curation Health from July 2019 to February 2026, staying on after the company was bought in 2024 by Reveleer, and ran the home healthcare program at Advantmed from Feb. 9 to July 13, 2026. In a video interview released in March, a friend called him a renaissance guy, an author and a guitarist as well as a doctor, and recalled that during the pandemic Lambert would open 7 a.m. work meetings by playing guitar.

In December, Lambert told a reporter the dispute had affected every part of his life, including his sleep and his eating. He said he prided himself on his resilience and had been surprised by how much it had worn on him.

Mayor Muriel Bowser called the shooting a "senseless act of gun violence" and said the White House had been briefed. Investigators are still piecing together the exact timeline, and Carroll said police believe the civil case is tied to the motive.

If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.

Share

Most read

This week

  1. Nearly 150 Ill On Cruise Ship Still At Sea

    World

    148 Sickened Aboard Caribbean Princess, CDC Says

  2. Hot Holiday Gift Recalled After Gruesome Burns

    Business

    Allstar Recalls 265,000 Sharper Image Fire Pits After Burns

  3. Prison Bus Crashes Into Tanker Loaded With Fuel

    Business

    18 Hurt in Missouri Crash Involving Prison Bus and Ethanol Tanker

  4. TV Star Killed After Being Struck By Car

    Entertainment

    Larry Poindexter Dies at 66, Days After Being Hit by Car

  5. Trump's Hidden Feud With Vance Exposed

    Politics

    Trump Faults Vance for Not Defending Iran War Decision, Report Says